by Ashley Cowie

April 27, 2020

from Ancient-Origins Website

Italian version

Close-up of the Göbekli Tepe site

in central Turkey.

Source: Brian Weed / Adobe stock

Does a "hidden-pattern" at Göbekli Tepe in central Turkey suggest 12,000-year-old hunter-gatherers knew rudimentary geometric principals, indicating a more complex society than previously assumed by archaeologists, or not?

The first phase of construction at the famous Göbekli Tepe, or "potbellied hill" in Turkish, has been dated to between 12,000 and 11,000 years ago, and this prehistoric stone circle, located on a barren hilltop in southeastern Turkey, has challenged archaeologists' ideas about prehistoric cultures since its discovery in the 1990s.

Many leading archaeologists have been perplexed as to how the assumed to be primitive hunter-gatherers could design and assemble such a massive monumental stone structure before the emergence of the social order that came with agriculture?

Now, Israeli archaeologists, Gil Haklay and his PhD advisor Avi Gopher, of Tel Aviv University, have published a new study (Geometry and Architectural Planning at Göbekli Tepe, Turkey) in the Cambridge Archaeological Journal providing a set of observations suggesting this prehistoric building project was,

"much more complex than previously thought",

...and that it required planning and resources to a degree thought of as being impossible for those times.

Three Contemporaneous Stone Circles, Perhaps?

At this world-renowned archaeological site several concentric stone circles feature massive T-shaped pillars that reach almost 6 meters (20 ft) in height with animals and anthropological motifs carved in relief.

But this new study focuses on the arrangement and positioning of the three oldest circular stone enclosures at Göbekli Tepe and the researchers claim that underlying the entire architectural plan of these three structures is,

"a hidden geometric pattern," which they describe as being "specifically an equilateral triangle."

Close-up of a stone pillar at Göbekli Tepe

with an intricate relief carving.

(Zhengan / CC BY-SA 4.0 )
 

Until these new observations, most archaeologists had assumed that the circles at Göbekli Tepe had been built gradually, over a long time period, possibly by different cultural groups, and that older circles were covered over with the new.

Never was it considered that all three enclosures might have been constructed,

"as a single unit at the same time," said the researchers.

Researcher Haklay told Haaretz that while the initial discovery of the site was a big surprise for the archaeological world, his new research confirms its construction was even "more complex than we thought."

New "Single Project" Theory Challenges the Mainstream

The new study focuses on enclosures B, C, and D, which have been dated to slightly older than enclosure A, and Haklay, who was previously an architect, applied a method of interpretation known as "architectural formal analysis" to retrace the ancient builders planning principles and methodologies.

Using an algorithm, Haklay identified the center points of the three irregular stone circles, which fell roughly mid-way between the pair of central pillars in each enclosure.

The eureka moment came when the three central points were found to form a nearly perfect equilateral triangle, so accurate in measure, that the researchers say the,

"vertices are about 25 centimeters (10 inches) away from forming a perfect triangle with sides measuring 19.25 meters (63 ft) each".
 

The Göbekli Tepe site in central Turkey.

(Teomancimit / CC BY-SA 3.0 )

And for those readers thinking this occurrence might be a coincidence, Haklay told reporters at Haaretz that the enclosures,

"all have different sizes and shapes" and he says the odds that the three center points would form an equilateral triangle by chance, "are very low."

This complex abstract floor design underlying the arrangement of Göbekli Tepe, is presented in the new paper as evidence of a "scaled floor plan," possibly achieved using reeds of equal length to create a rudimentary blueprint on the ground, Haklay suggests.

The archaeologist also thinks each enclosure subsequently went through a long construction history with multiple modifications, but that in the initial building phase,

"they started as a single project"...

Does the New "All Three At Once" Theory Challenge the Time Delayed Hypothesis'?

If the underlying geometric pattern is indeed evidence that the three structures at Göbekli Tepe had been built in one ancient engineering project, the feat was three times larger than previously thought, requiring a similar multiplication of hunter-gatherer builders, resources and effort.

Gopher suggests maybe,

"thousands of workers marked",

...what he called the birth of a more stratified society, with a level of sophistication equitable with much later sedentary groups of farmers.

In conclusion, while the two researchers are convinced their discovery proves the three stone circles had been built contemporaneously, many readers will at this moment, like me, be struggling with a contrasting proposition.

What if the earliest builders erected a stand-alone circle then a later culture built another one, randomly positioned, beside the first with no geometric correlation.

Then a third set of builders, perhaps 2000 years later, decided to build their circle equidistant from the previously unrelated first two circles, resulting in an equilateral triangle by independent, although connected design thinking, or even dare we say, by chance?